Friday, November 18, 2011

Review: Sungmin talks with HaeHae


Author: mrslee19


Title: 5/5
-       Your title was to the point, and would attract readers who like Sungmin and Donghae.
-       It gave a hint on the storyline and the ages of your characters in the story as you used ‘HaeHae’.

Description/Foreword: 8/10
-       Your description was clear, but there was a spelling error (‘cutier’). However, I ignored it as it was from your previous story, this story’s prequel.
-       If you had added a brief summary of the previous story mentioned, it would have been even better.
-       You can further improve your description section by organizing it. For example, put all the characters and their details (ages, etc.) together under a Heading.
-       Your foreword mentioned where you got your idea from, which is good.
-       You didn’t reveal too much of the story, and you were able to interest the readers.

Characters: 15/15
-       You had no problems in your characterization.
-       The characters’ feelings for people around them were shown very well.
-       The characters’ emotions, feelings, thoughts, etc were clear.

Plot: 30/30
-       The plot was great! Full marks awarded! ^^ Need I say more?

Flow/Pace: 5/5
-       It flowed very smoothly, and the pace was just right(:

Writing Style: 10/10
-       You have a writing style that keeps the readers absorbed in your story.

Originality/Creativity: 5/5
-       Definitely original, and very creative~

Punctuation/Spelling/Tenses/Grammar/Vocabulary: 10/15
-       Punctuation and spelling were fine.
-       Try to write in the past tense.
-       Try to work on your grammar and sentence phrasing.
-       Your foundation in vocabulary is there(:

Personal Enjoyment: 5/5
-       I ABSOLUTELY LOVED YOUR STORY ♥

Marks Achieved: 93/100
Grade: A+

~~~~~~~

Corrections

Try to write in the past tense. Some words were incorrectly used. For example, ‘he's been welcomed by a raised eyebrow of his friend Hyukjae’ should be ‘he got welcomed with a raised eyebrow from his friend, Hyukjae’. For this, I recommend you to read more. You have to see a phrase a few times before you can register it in your mind permanently. Reading is the best way to do so. Other than such errors, you have no problems at all.

Side Note:

You made a new record. This is the first A+ I’ve given. SIMPLY E-X-C-E-L-L-E-N-T. Keep it up!~ ^^

♥ cheonsa

~~~~~~~

No comments :

Post a Comment